Billed as a romance because of a subplot involving an aimless boy who takes her lifeguarding job when she can no longer do it, this story is really about Tess's struggle to rejig her plans and salvage the vital parts of her dream that are attainable. But it's hard to see the struggle and the focus necessary to succeed when Tess keeps screwing around. Tess frankly lacks discipline. I lost my faith in her by the third time she snuck out of the house and broke all of the warnings of her doctors (and -- surprise! -- got very sick). If you face a protagonist up against an insurmountable disease, you need to give the woman some spunk, some fortitude, and some will. But screwing up and then wallowing in self-pity got plain old and that seemed to be all Tess had to offer. I don't have the patience that her parents (or apparently her coaches) had. On a bleak positive note, I appreciated that at the end of the novel we don't see Tess getting rewarded with the happy fulfillment all of her dreams. A realistic bittersweet ending was the least the author could offer us.
Saturday, May 25, 2024
Breathing Underwater, by Abbey Lee Nash
Friday, May 24, 2024
The Lightning Circle, by Vikki Vansickle (ill by Laura K. Watson)
It doesn't help that it's her first summer and she's never been a camper herself. Being a camp "virgin," every ritual is a surprise for her and she approaches the experience like it is a foreign land. But with good instincts and a little help, she manages to survive the summer and learns a great deal, growing to love the place and its people.
A beautiful piece of nostalgia for the summer camp experience, this novel in verse is illustrated with sketches of camp miscellania (a bunk, a horse, a pencil, fellow campers, etc.) that beautifully evoke the innocence of the experience. It is a very gentle story with no particularly severe traumas but instead chock full of authentic memories lovingly retold by the author. While fictional, you can't make stuff like this up, so it is clearly drawn from Vansickle's own childhood at camp (in the afterward, she admits as much).
For anyone who was lucky enough to go to camp, reading this book will send you down memory lane. For others, the book and its exploration of friendships formed and social skills learned in a summer will explain the appeal of this rite of passage. Definitely a children's book much better appreciated by adults!
Sunday, May 19, 2024
The Boy You Always Wanted, by Michelle Quach
Francine is a good student and extremely conscientious, but none of that has made her popular at school. The only male acquaintance she can think of would be Ollie and they are hardly friends. Ollie for his part is always a bit amused by Francine, but doesn't think of her as a friend either. And he certainly has no interest in participating in what Francine has taken to calling "The Plan." But when Ollie turns out to need Francine's help, the two of them devise a transactional arrangement and Ollie finds himself sucked into Francine's family's drama. It's actually a welcome change for Ollie because his family couldn't be any more distant from each other. And while the entire set-up is based on deceit, a true attachment arises that proves to be surprisingly genuine.
The creepy premise of the story initially put me off the story, but it ends well and the truth is surprisingly liberating. Largely a story about family and about learning to accept change, everyone gets a chance to learn a thing or two. While there are a few rough spots and a subplot about a scheming best friend that never quite connects with the main story nor becomes the humor relief it is intended to serve, I enjoyed the cultural details and the nuanced characters.
Saturday, May 18, 2024
Playing for Keeps, by Jennifer Dugan
Ivy gave up playing when she was young, but she never lost her love of sport; she just found a new way to express it -- by officiating games. Just as June has laser focused on her pitching skills, Ivy has dedicated herself to the dream of one day becoming one of the few women to ever ref for the NFL. Now, if she could get her parents on board with the dream! But they want her to go to college and study something practical.
Girls with dreams of making it big, but who fall in love with each other instead. For Ivy, this is disastrous as referees can't date players, so they have to keep everything hush hush. For June, things are worse as she not only has the relationship to keep secret, she also is having physical problems with her throwing arm that are getting harder and harder to hide.
With all that going on, there is plenty of action to move this story, but the real high drama comes from the fiery romance itself. Neither June nor Ivy are particularly emotionally mature and theirs is a romance that is more often off than on. That provides plenty of opportunity for fights and counsel with BFFs (whom neither girl pays much attention to). But I found them hard to digest and relate to (and even hard to differentiate from each other). I liked the story well enough, but the characters simply didn't interest me. That made the novel a slow read.
Saturday, May 11, 2024
Conditions of a Heart, by Bethany Mangle
The primary characteristic of the
disease that Brynn Kwan suffers from is the easy tendency of her joints to
dislocate. Keeping herself intact (as well as managing the pain of her
condition) is a major undertaking and an obsession. In a similar fashion,
she's tried to hide her condition from her classmates as she's found how
uncomfortable her illness makes other people. But when she finds herself
accidentally in the middle of a schoolyard skirmish and gets suspended because
of it, all of her careful plans come apart. Prohibited from the social
activities that give her something to look forward to, she suffers an
existential crisis.
Any story introducing a new
condition (in this case, Ehlers-Danlos syndrome) is intrinsically interesting
to me. Giving us an opportunity to explore how this chronic disease
challenges Brynn and how she faces that challenge is a good part of the drama
of the story and I ate that stuff up. And while the occasionally repeated
rant about how the post-COVID world abandoned the disabled is muddy and
unclear, there are a lot of good points about how prevalent ableism is in our
society. That is the novel's strong suit and it does it well.
Much of that was expected. What I didn't expect was how funny the book would be. Brynn's cat cafe-owning cousin steals the show in the otherwise slow second act as we wait for Brynn to get her life together. And Brynn's sister, while insufferably self-centered, pulls off her narcissism in such a purely unself-conscious way that you just have to love her as much as Brynn actually does. The grownups, the antagonists, and the allies (off-on-off boyfriend included) are disposable, but I didn't mind that in the midst of Brynn's combustible performance.
Thursday, May 09, 2024
The Absinthe Underground, by Jamie Pacton
While the storytelling (with its persistent habit of overly convenient late reveals) annoyed me, the story itself is exquisite. Combining Belle Epoque with fantasy creates a beautiful setting for some nail-biting suspense as the girls work through a series of problems. Their very slow developing (and largely chaste) romance comes off with perfect timing. The characters themselves are distinct in numerous ways and well-developed. I enjoyed the humor, the writing, and the originality of the novel.
Wednesday, May 01, 2024
Home Away From Home, by Cynthia Lord
But the summer is full of surprises. There's Cayman himself, who turns out to have a complicated history and is much less of a threat than Mia first imagined. There's a stray cat who is hanging around the house for whom no one can find a family. And there's a rare bird -- a Gyrfalcon -- that has blown off-course and taken to harassing the local resident Bald Eagles. And when Mia makes a tragic mistake that endangers the bird, everything changes.
I found this to be a satisfying middle reader with lessons about personal responsibility and caring for others. There are lots of details about birds and cats and the proper care of each to satisfy young curious minds. And there are nice dynamics between Mia, Grandma, and Cayman. While the topic of alcoholism is briefly brought up, it is handled in a very safe and age-appropriate manner.
Saturday, April 27, 2024
For Girls Who Walk Through Fire, by Kim DeRose
Saturday, April 20, 2024
The Lost Library, by Rebecca Stead and Wendy Mass
Told from three perspectives (Ryan, a ghost librarian, and
the library’s cat Mortimer), this latest outing by Stead and Mass has all of the
quirky fun (and hidden lessons) of their previous foray Bob. I especially enjoyed Mortimer and his atypical relationship with the local mice. It has a few flaws. At times, the story strays into subplots
that the authors don’t really seem to want to develop. Older readers will find the
mysteries largely lacking in suspense as well.
However, I found it overall to be an entertaining, brisk, and generally
fun mystery novel.
Wednesday, April 17, 2024
Unraveller, by Frances Hardinge
Kellen has found himself in possession of the ability to unravel curses. But the power comes with caveats: he must know who made the curse and why the curse was made. For now, he uses the power as a means to make a modest living, but as word of his potential gets around, the power makes Kellen a target.
Someone is rescuing accused cursers and abducting people with unhatched curse eggs. And that same someone has now cursed Kellen. All he knows is that the person is somehow connected with a shadow organization called Salvation that lurks in the dangerous and untamed wilds outside of human civilization. So, he joins up with his friend Nettle, her cursed brother Yannick (who lives life as a sea gull), and the help of a warrior and his bonded horse monster, and they head into the wilds to find out who is doing all of this. Along the way, they uncover the mystery of where curse eggs come from and why Kellen is able to unravel curses.
Its a long and very complicated fantasy adventure with a delightfully original internal logic and lots of twists and turns. I particularly enjoyed the logic of curses, an idea that combines magic with some behavioral observations about the way anger and grudges can consume a person and about how unsatisfying revenge truly is.
Friday, April 12, 2024
You Are Here: Connecting Flights, ed Ellen Oh.
I enjoyed all of the writers, which is pretty unusual for a collection, and especially so given the similiarity of the stories. Almost all of the stories involve their characters embarking on a trip back to Asia (usually for the first time) and their fears about making the trip. That could have grown old quite quickly, but surprisingly it doesn't. Each character approaches the problem differently and not all of them resolve the same way.
The acts of racism that tie everything together didn't work as well for me. It is important to discuss anti-Asian sentiment, especially in the aftermath of the Covid-19 Pandemic, but what's here isn't believable. Instead of stirring indignation, it just felt petty and fake. Of course, the reason it is so camped up is because this book is targeted at middle readers. However, I think even young readers can be trusted to realize that you don't have to clownishly shout "go back to China" to be racist. So, while I think the intent was good and the purpose was important, I would have strongly preferred a more realistic (and thus more provocative) depiction of the ways that Asian-Americans experience prejudice.
Tuesday, April 09, 2024
Something Like Home, by Andrea Beatriz Arango
And when things don't work out quite as she planned, Laura finds that there are other solutions. Like the abandoned stray puppy that she brings home and trains to become a therapy dog. Like the boy at school whom no one likes, but who Laura learns is dealing with his own problems. Or like her aunt, who is struggling just as much as Laura to figure out this new arrangement.
A sweet, albeit rather predictable middle grade book in verse about a girl figuring out how to adapt to changing circumstances she cannot control (and finding a few things that she can control along the way). It contains a smattering of Spanish and Laura and her family are Puerto Rican, but these are not particularly integral to the story (despite the novel being a Belpre Honor book). Instead, the story deals with the concept of family and home and how both are wherever you find them.
Saturday, April 06, 2024
Ellie Haycock Is Totally Normal, by Gretchen Schreiber
Books about sick kids tend to grab you by the emotional jugalar and take no prisoners, and for that reason many readers shy away from them altogether. Usually at least some of the characters die (and maybe a few will live and get better). Regardless, they are difficult books to read. I've been drawn in the past to books that took the formula and did something exceptional to it and thus loved John Green's The Fault In Our Stars for its humor and its tough protagonists. This book has some particular virtues worth calling out.
First of all, the novel's look at illness feels fresh. Ellie is a jaded patient with a learned cynicism towards the medical profession. Her devastating take on doctor hubris and the vanity of nurses (or is that doctor vanity and the hubris of nurses?) won't surprise anyone who's spent a significant time in a hospital, but it's an approach that is surprisingly rare in literature. Secondly, there's the novel idea of choosing a disease -- VACTERL -- that can't actually be curied. Rather, it's a disease with a moderate survival rate that helps ensure (spoiler alert!) that Ellie isn't going to have a tragic death. But she isn't going to be cured either. And both she and we have to accept that and be comfortable that the ending isn't going to be about Ellie's medical transformation.
In the end, this is not a story about a disease or Ellie's brave fight with it, but a story about Ellie herself. And while there is some tremedous emotional growth shown when Ellie learns to trust her friends a bit more and open her heart, the really stellar performance is between Ellie and her mother. For the first half of the book, I really loathed Ellie's self-obsessed and narcisistic mother. The blog, which is liberally quoted, amounts to endless whining from Mom about how much she's suffered, how unappreciative her daughter is, how hard she's trying to be a good mother, ad nauseum. But at the same time, Ellie is horribly cruel in her lack of sympathy for her parents in a way that (while you can see where it is coming from) is really painful to read. It takes a major showdown between mother and daughter for them to break out of their toxic relationship and that provides the most emotional part of the story.
In other words, this is not a story that will break your heart because Ellie is a fine young woman struggling with a horribly painful and debilitating rare chronic condition. It is a story that will make you cry because it is about parents and children wrestling with a much more common chronic and debilitating condition: parents learning how to let your children become adults and children figuring out how to grow into being that adult. Universal and relatable, and ultimately empowering and hopeful. Tears, but ones that feel good.
Tuesday, April 02, 2024
The Big Sting, by Rachelle Delaney
These personality traits get tested when the family goes to visit grandpa on a remote island off of the coast of British Columbia. One night grandma's beehives are stolen and the kids and their grandfather launch a search to find them. While Leo is reluctant to do something as risky as to try hunting down potentially dangerous bee thieves, he rises to the occasion, proving that labels aren't everything.
Pleasant and lively middle reader. The life lessons are largely in second place to a riotous cast of quirky supporting characters and some low-key adventuring. While the kids fall into some dangerous situations, there's nothing too scary and Leo largely saves the day. Sadly, there's not not very much on bees themselves.
Saturday, March 30, 2024
The Girl Next Door, by Cecilia Vinesse
Marianne and Cleo are next-door neighbors and once upon a time they were best friends too, but they went their separate ways. In their shared misery they rebond quickly and, when the people around them start to assume that they are dating, they decide to go along with the plot. But what starts as fake dating to get back at their unfaithful partners becomes a real relationship.
While the plot sounds largely unremarkable and a bit contrived, the novel is well-written and breathes a bit of freshness into an old story. The setting is dense and immersive. That means both that it relishes its details and the realistic feeling that such details gives its charcaters and also that it takes a bit to keep all of those details straight. I had some trouble getting into the story and was frustrated by the lack of distinctiveness to all of the players.
Monday, March 25, 2024
Elf Dog & Owl Head, by M. T. Anderson (ill Junyi Wu)
A rollicking adventure of strange creatures, battles, and subterfuge. Filled out with delightful illustrations, this fast-paced story is an easy read. I found it terribly violent and a bit thin on character, but it won plenty of awards (including a Newbery Honor last year).
Sunday, March 24, 2024
With A Little Luck, by Marissa Meyer
Defying the odds, he finds a rare signed record that everyone's overlooked, he wins a radio contest for two tickets to see a British hearthrob in concert, he finds missing homework, and he's rolling d20s perpetually. With the tickets, he gets the courage to ask Maya out on a date and she surprisingly accepts. And then she surprises him further revealing that she loves fantasy roleplaying as well and becomes an essential part of his D&D parties! It would seem that there is no limit to the things that Jude can do with his magic die until, that is, his luck changes.
Maya turns out to be a lovely person but not the love of his life. His true love is actually with someone else. His grade start slipping again. Every good deed he tries to perform backfires on him. It would seem that the die has now cursed him and he can only roll d1s. But for everything that goes wrong, some new opportunity arrives. Jude begins to discern that it isn't a simple matter of good and bad luck.
For a novel based (as its predecessor Instant Karma was) around Beatles references, the lesson of this story actually comes to us from the Stones -- "you can't always get what you want...you get what you need." As Jude's luck seems to reverse, he comes to understand that luck itself is overrated. And the best things in life are not determined by fate, but by courage and taking chances.
Continuing the unobtrusive magical nature that Meyer played with in Instant Karma, there are plenty of similarities but is is an imminently more satisfying story. Prudence and Quint from that book play minor roles here to give us some foundation, but Jude's struggles to gain self-confidence and his acts of bravery are much more relatable that Pru's acts of karmic vengeance. And while a string of hillariously improbable coincidences at the end of the story might have derailed the whole thing, they in fact are quite in keeping with the spirit of this fun and enjoyable read.
Sunday, March 17, 2024
Cupid's Revenge, by Wibke Brueggemann
Katherine doesn't seem very impressed with Teddy but Katherine and Tilly have instant chemsitry and that makes things awkward. Tilly knows better than to date Katherine, but the heart wants what the heart wants. And, anyway, you know how this trope works so I don't really need to lay out the rest of the story. Furthermore, the setting -- rehearsing a play -- is tiredly familiar. No surprises!
What's a little more off script is the rest of the story: Tilly's oddball family of professional musicians and dancers (so, so unlike Tilly) are colorful and humorour. The drama of taking care of Tilly's recently-diagnosed-with-dementia grandfather, who's come to live with them and proves to be alternatingly a huge handful and a great help, provides pathos.
Full of humor, some lovely romance, frank depictions of sex, and a fantastic cast of characters, Cupid's Revenge (the novel) is a stand out for both refreshing a tired plot and being a surprisingly good read. I have a poor record with British YA (or NA, in this case) as it tends to be preachy and condescending, but this book surprised me. It's not just a heroine with a good head on her shoulders but a full cast of characters who act like normal people and behave sensibly. The story and its humor comes through so much bettter without lots of false drama and contrived circumstances.
Thursday, March 14, 2024
Drawing Deena, by Hena Khan
Deena is also capable of solving her own problems. With some help from her friends, they help set up a social media site for her mother's business. They develop policies and plans for her mother's commercial success. Along the way, Deena learns to stand up for herself and her family.
Full of lots of ethnic details (mostly about clothing and food), Khan's book is really about portraying a typical American malaise: children stressing themselves sick. What it doesn't do is spend much time on the treatment. Rather, Deena just sort of recovers at the end, gaining assertiveness and confidence. So, even though there's plenty said about Deena's condition and its prognosis, there's hardly anything on strategies for stress relief. That makes her recovery something of an article of faith rather than a shared journey and sucks much of the pay-off out of the story.
Monday, March 11, 2024
Ruptured, by Joanne Rossmassler Fritz
Claire wavers over whether she should tell anyone what her mother said. Perhaps she no longer believes it. But what will happen when Mom does remember what she was feeling? Claire's previously distant Dad has been devotedly doting on his wife. Perhaps, his actions can make up for whatever triggered her mother's doubts about the marriage in the first place?
This quick read is all the more speedy for being written in verse. It's not a particularly compelling use of the method and mostly just allows the action to race ahead without much attention to character development. Outside of Claire herself, there isn't much room to expand on much of anyone. There's some sketchy drama with a friend and some set backs in Mom's recovery, but these are glossed over. I found it pretty thin.