I enjoyed all of the writers, which is pretty unusual for a collection, and especially so given the similiarity of the stories. Almost all of the stories involve their characters embarking on a trip back to Asia (usually for the first time) and their fears about making the trip. That could have grown old quite quickly, but surprisingly it doesn't. Each character approaches the problem differently and not all of them resolve the same way.
The acts of racism that tie everything together didn't work as well for me. It is important to discuss anti-Asian sentiment, especially in the aftermath of the Covid-19 Pandemic, but what's here isn't believable. Instead of stirring indignation, it just felt petty and fake. Of course, the reason it is so camped up is because this book is targeted at middle readers. However, I think even young readers can be trusted to realize that you don't have to clownishly shout "go back to China" to be racist. So, while I think the intent was good and the purpose was important, I would have strongly preferred a more realistic (and thus more provocative) depiction of the ways that Asian-Americans experience prejudice.
No comments:
Post a Comment