Wednesday, May 14, 2025

One Step Forward, by Marcie Flinchum Atkins

Teen-aged Matilda, growing up in a radical family in Washington DC, finds inspiration supporting and eventually protesting for the Suffragists.  Told in verse, the novel traces her involvement (including her presence at the "Night of Terror") to the eventual ratification of the Nineteenth Amendment.  Rooted in well-documented history, Atkins gives herself license to explore the mind of the youngest radical suffragist.

There's no faulting the retelling of historical facts, many of which may be only hazily known by readers and the idea of focusing on a teen makes the novel inspirational for young readers.  However, for a story rich with people and events, the verse format provides too sketchy of a treatment.  And while the poetry is definitely above average, it can prove distracting and distancing to the storytelling.  That frustrates attempts to understand the events of the story.  Reading a more traditional historical account alongside this novel would prove beneficial and in fact be a useful complement.

Monday, May 05, 2025

The Enemy's Daughter, by Anne Blankman

At the onset of the Great War, twelve year-old Marta and her father are caught overseas in America and must undertake a dangerous trip under false papers to return home to Germany.  Unfortunately, they choose to cross the Atlantic aboard the Lusitania and when that boat is sunk by the German Navy they narrowly survive.  On land, her father is arrested as a suspected spy and Marta flees.  Alone but sharp-witted, Marta finds her way to York where she befriends an Irish girl whose family gives her a home.  But with all Germans considered to be dangerous enemies, Marta must conceal her identity.

Torn between her love for her country and the undeniable cruelty of the German navy in sinking a civilian ship, Marta still believes that Germany is in the right.  But living amongst the English for several months, she begins to wonder if it all isn't a bit more complicated than she's learned in school.  Her Irish friend hates Germans as fervently as she hates the English, yet the two girls have nonetheless become best friends.

A lovely adventure, but with a glacial pace and the repetitive storytelling.  Its two themes ("there are no sides" and all people can be good or bad) are well-established and then driven home in again and again.  Those are fine messages but become boring in their repetition.  Some of that is of course the story's limitations.  The premise is interesting, but there isn't very much that can be done with the character.  There's only so much adventure that one can plausibly subject a twelve year-old to in a middle reader.

Tuesday, April 29, 2025

Aisle Nine, by Ian X. Cho

The day that multiple portals to hell opened up around the world, spewing out blood thirsty demons, everything changed.  While retail had always been hell, the opening of a gateway to Hades in Aisle Nine (homewares) of the Here For You discount store made working there even more challenging.  But some well-placed coupons and a detachment of soldiers with flame throwers kept footfall at acceptable levels.  For while there are a couple of "doomers" who have given up and live in constant despair, most people go about their business, shopping, and trying to collect points by passing a roadblock or witnessing a demon slaying.  After all, most people have their lives to live.

Jasper works at the Here For You.  Try as he might, he has no real memories of the past for Hell on Earth arrived.  There are people who seem to know him (like a trainee security guard named Kyle) and he discovered his job when he happened to walk into the store and got cornered by his manager.  However, he has the same recurring nightmare in which the world comes to an end.  And it's coming soon -- on Black Friday.  With some help from Kyle and a friendly pet demon, he plans to stop all of that, dodging crazy shoppers and bloodthirsty monsters (same thing?) and save the world.

Initially, the book is an absolutely hilarious and original farce that imagines what would happen if the end of the world came and no one cared so long as they could keep shopping.  The story loses its fun as the farce peters out about half way through and the plot turns serious (or as serious as it can, given the premise).  But while I loved the premise, I just couldn't get into the largely nonsensical story and weak characters.

Saturday, April 26, 2025

Twenty-Four Seconds from Now...: A Love Story, by Jason Reynolds

At this exact moment, Neon is in the bathroom.  In his girlfriend's bedroom, she's waiting for him to return so they can have sex for the first time.  Flash back twenty-four seconds before that and he's considering what is coming up.  Flash back twenty-four minutes and he's getting to her house.  Flash back twenty-four hours....and so on.

Each chapter takes us back in time as Neon relives the moments that led to this big one.  Despite being billed as a "love story," this is not a romance so much as a story of how Neon was taught the values that go on to inform his conduct.  His parents and his sister have talked to him about sex.  His grandfather also shaped those values.  And while the story is told in reverse, it all makes sense in the end.

It's Christopher Nolan's Momento meets Judy Blume's Forever, with a Black American perspective. Lots of potential and a big gimmick, but it doesn't really pan out for me.  There are moments that shine (I particularly liked the minister's eulogy at grandfather's funeral) but much of the story is simply not that interesting.  And the reverse timeline is a difficult thing to pull off in a genre that relies so much on building on top of what we already know.  For example, it's really hard to feel much for the couple's meet cute when it happens near the end of the book.  So many of the details are known long before they happen that the usual emotional build up doesn't occur.

Monday, April 14, 2025

Book Uncle and Me, by Uma Krishnaswami

On the corner near Yasmin's apartment, an old man she calls "Book Uncle" runs a free library, offering books to anyone who comes by.  Every day, Yasmin returns a book and gets a new one from him.  She's read over 400 books from him so far.  They are always perfect choices.  When he gives her a book with an ancient Indian fable about a hunter and a group of doves.  She doesn't understand the story, but Book Uncle tells her it will make sense one day.

Then one day, Book Uncle and his cart of books are missing!  He's been ordered to close his library!  Yasmin is bereft and asks around for what she can do about it.  Everyone knows that there is a big mayoral election going on.  Maybe she and her classmates could write letters to try to convince the candidates to support Book Uncle.  They do so and find a sympathetic candidate.  But when the children help to get their pro-Book Uncle candidate elected, they discover that not all is smooth sailing.

A beautiful and short tale about the power of people to shape the world.  Yasmin's efforts to stand up for what is right is particularly inspirational.  Set in urban India, there are plenty of lovely cultural details that will be both alien and yet somehow familiar to readers.

The first of a series.

Sunday, April 13, 2025

Warrior Girl Unearthed, by Angeline Boulley

Perry doesn't have much use for school and would rather spend the summer (and most school days) fishing in the lake.  But when she is forced to enroll in the Tribal Council Interns program, she finds herself paired up with the curator of the Tribe's museum.  He takes her to visit an anthropologist at the local state school, where she is shocked to learn about the way that her ancestors (and their sacred effects) are being treated by archeologists.  Boxes of dismembered body parts left in cellars, funereal items auctioned off, and an ineffectual Federal law that is supposed to prevent all of these abuses from occurring and is instead ignored.

Now committed to returning the remains of a young woman that is housed in the college's archives, Perry gets embroiled in an even bigger discovery -- a cache of bodies stolen from local graves.  But effecting the repatriation of these remains brings Perry into an even bigger issue.  Young women are being abducted across their reservation and due to loopholes in Federal and Tribal jurisdictions, help is slow in coming.  What does the one have to do with the other?  That's for the surprising climax of this mystery, thriller, and screed to reveal.
 
I struggled a bit with the complexity of the story -- numerous subplots, characters, and heavy use of Ojibwan phrases makes for a thick soup -- but it also creates a deep and immersive environment.  At least a dozen major characters, each of them have their own particular motivations, leads to a series of plot twists that keep you guessing to the end.  It's a well-crafted story and despite its complexity pays off at the end.  

While I might have enjoyed reading the first book Firekeeper's Daughter before I tackled this one, there really was no need to do so.  The novel stands up well on its own.

Thursday, April 10, 2025

Where Do You See Yourself, by Claire Forrest

Effie wishes that the world would see her as the capable young woman that she feels she is.  But as the girl in the wheelchair she finds she has to fight for just about everything that comes easily to others.  From teachers to her parents, no one seems to expect much from her and she finds her wishes written off.  And that includes where she'll go to school.

When she graduates, her parents expect her to go to college somewhere nearby, but Effie has her eye on a mass media program in New York City.  Life in NYC will be challenging for a person in a wheelchair and her parents try to discourage her.  So to prove that she can handle it, she takes some brave steps to stand up for herself at her high school.  And when that goes well, her parents relent.  But when she gets to New York on a school visit, she's disappointed to find that the same old struggles for accommodation await her there.

Effie is a protagonist with an exciting voice and interesting insights on being a teen with a disability.  There's a lot of serious matters discussed here, but Effie approaches them with strength and a sense of humor that makes her a real winner to the reader.  In a time when caring for the needs of others has become so politically charged, having a bit of a grounding here is good for the soul.  And it's a beautiful story about finding out what is important in one's life and becoming the things that you want.