Felix and his mother Astrid have gradually been slipping through cracks in the social net. Suffering from emotional issues, Astrid can't hold down a job. After getting shuffled from one place to another, they have ended up living in a van, moving it from time to time in order to avoid arousing suspicion. Felix longs for stability and a fixed address. With a home, they could have simple things like a bathroom! At school, he manages to do well. He has two close friends, but he can't tell them why he can't invite them home for fear that they will report his mother to the authorities.
Felix also has an incredible head for trivia and he's a whiz playing along with the contestants on the TV quiz show "Who, What, Where, When." When the producers of that show announce a special junior edition, he's excited to apply for a slot and ecstatic when he is invited on the show. But it is the discovery that there is a large cash prize for the winner which raises the stakes. With that money, he could get them an apartment and help get Astrid back up on her feet.
While I hate child endangerment stories, the book works for me for two reasons. First of all, because the usual sadistic litany of misfortunes is kept to a minimum. We get there is a lot of challenges in his living situation but it is not utterly hopeless. But what really helps is the way that the tough times are countered by sweetness. Nielsen has chosen to highlight the kindness that people can do for each other. Several times there are opportunities for hard things to get worse (for example, when Felix is caught stealing food) but the story chooses to show people being kind (the grocer, after initially threatening the boy takes him in and feeds him). The message is that being kind and generous to those truly in need (or even simply decent) can pay off. The happy/weepy and ultimately satisfying ending doesn't hurt either!
Friday, September 27, 2019
Saturday, September 21, 2019
Braced, by Alyson Gerber
Rachel has really been improving her soccer game and coach has
started letting her play on offense. She
even bends the rules to let Rachel off for a last-minute doctor’s
appointment. Unfortunately, the doctor has
bad news: Rachel has developed a
curvature in her spine – scholiosis – and will need to wear a back brace for at
least the next six months for most of the day.
Suddenly, all of Rachel’s dreams (soccer, most of all) are threatened by
having to wear the hideous uncomfortable appliance. It makes every movement uncomfortable and
derails her game. Soon, coach has her
back on defense and won’t even let her start.
She hates the way she looks in it and the way people look at her, but
most of all she hates feeling like a freak.
A sensitive and insightful middle reader about a health
issue of relevance to its target audience.
Many girls develop spinal issues in middle school or have a classmate
who does. As the only boy in my class
who was diagnosed with scholiosis (I was lucky enough to not need a brace),
this particular story spoke to me directly and I think I might have enjoyed a
book like it at the time.
Gerber has done an excellent job creating a story that is
entertaining to read, yet full of facts about the disease and its
treatment. That the characters are authentic
and interesting is a bonus, as are the realistic family interactions. For me, stories stand out when they either do
something new (rare) or take on an issue which has been written about
before. This is a good example of the
latter.
Saturday, September 14, 2019
The Rest of the Story, by Sarah Dessen
After her father’s wedding, while Dad and his new wife are honeymooning in Greece, the plan was for Emma to stay
at her friend’s house. And when that plan falls
through, the only option that they can come up with is to send Emma to stay
with her maternal grandmother in North Lake.
Emma has only ever been to North Lake once (when she was
four) and has no memory of the visit.
But before her mother died, Emma used to love to hear stories of the Lake, even if the stories always seemed a bit fantastic and surreal.
Once there, Emma discovers that while she has no memory of the place, she has an eclectic
family and old friends that do. They even call her by her middle name ("Saylor") despite her efforts to explain that everyone back home calls her "Emma." They have plenty of stories about her
mother (and father) that fill in gaps for that Emma has always wondered about (e.g., how her parents really met, why her father never brought her back to visit, etc.).
The time goes by quickly and when her parents return to the States and come to get her, she finds that she wants to spend more time with this side of the family she doesn't know. It's then that she finds just how alienated her father is from the North Lake relations. Saylor/Emma is torn between the sides, a conflict only resolved by an Act of God.
A touching story of southern family life, with all the
poignancy for which Dessen is renown. The
writing is beautiful, even if the template is so well-worn: the intelligent young woman who
wrestles with her family for autonomy, the outsider boy who is intelligent and
responsible, and a tight group of friends who spend the summer goofing off. One of these days, Dessen will write a dystopian
and surprise me, but for now, it’s a
template that works.
In comparison with
her more recent books, this is stronger take on her perennial themes. There are a lot of characters, but surprisingly,
they can be sorted out. And the story,
which does resort to melodrama in the end, is generally interesting with a
touch of humor at the right moments. And for those who are regular Dessen readers, you can be assured that Spinnerbait appears!
Internment, by Samira Ahmed
In a near future United States, Muslims are rounded up by
the Exclusion Authority and sent to relocation camps, seventeen year-old Layla
and her parents among them. The camp they are sent to is located in a
remote desert camp (ironically near by the Manzanar camp used to detain
Japanese Americans during WWII). While Layla's initial concern is with the deprivation of her civil rights, things take a nastier turn is she finds her resistance met with extreme cruelty at the
hands of a sadistic camp administrator.
Mixing together elements of Japanese relocation, the
internment centers for migrants and asylum seekers of the current day, and
tossing in familiar current politics, Internment
is a dystopian with a no-apologies agenda. That has gotten it a lot of attention from both sides and can make reviewing the novel a bit of a challenge. I'm more than sympathetic with the political agenda, but overall I found this a blunt and exploitative instrument.
The thing about dystopians is that they work primarily
because they are subtle. They can be
read a literature, without even considering their political agenda. But there is nothing subtle about this novel. Like a social media echo chamber, this is all about momentary indignation with atrocity layered on top of atrocity. Occasional moments of reasoning and insight exist in the story, but they get swept aside pretty quickly for latest outrage.
The most egregious problem for me, though, wasn't the dumbed-down politics, but the adversary. The camp administrator (whose obesity is excessively mentioned) is so over-the-top and such a paper
tiger that he’s basically comic relief.
That provides a way-too-easy way out in the end. If Ahmed really wanted to
write the “courageous” book she claims to have written, she would never have
made evil so easy to wipe out. The evil that would
create these camps is not going to be defeated by people chanting slogans, it’s
going to take some hard looks at the forces that drive people to accept such policies. And it's not as if Ahmed doesn't know this (she brings it up on several occasions) but in the interest of actually resolving institutional racism and xenophobia in the confines of her novel she's oversimplified and then deftly "resolved" the problem. It's too bad that life isn't that simple and I don't feel that this novel serves any higher good. At best, this gives false confidence to left-wing Americans that they can defeat Trump simply by saying "resist."
Tuesday, September 03, 2019
The Runaway Princess, by Kate Coombs
The Kingdom of Greeve is plagued by a dragon, an evil witch, and a horde of bandits. To rid his kingdom of these woes, the King has announced that he'll give the hand of his daughter to whatever prince can do the job. Princess Margaret, however, has entirely different ideas. Resentful of being locked away in a tower for whatever prince comes along, she manages to escape and seeks to rid her kingdom of the pests herself, and kick out all the dumb princes to boot!
In fact, it is really the latter that are the greatest problem. The dragon is just a baby, the witch is kind, and the bandits are simply taking from the rich to give to the poor. But the princes are a menace! Prince Vantor, the worst of the bunch, means to win the competition at any cost, even if it involves kidnapping the Princess. But with help from her maid Dilly, the gardener boy Cam, and the young wizard Lex, Meg will figure the whole thing out.
Not really sure if it wants to be adventure or comedy, this tongue-in-cheek fractured fairy tale sometimes falls very flat. Still, it's light and action-packed. With well over a dozen major characters, the action gets a bit chaotic by the end but I'm pretty sure that everything gets wrapped up. And Meg even gets to start taking sword fighting lessons (and toss aside her hated embroidery)!
In fact, it is really the latter that are the greatest problem. The dragon is just a baby, the witch is kind, and the bandits are simply taking from the rich to give to the poor. But the princes are a menace! Prince Vantor, the worst of the bunch, means to win the competition at any cost, even if it involves kidnapping the Princess. But with help from her maid Dilly, the gardener boy Cam, and the young wizard Lex, Meg will figure the whole thing out.
Not really sure if it wants to be adventure or comedy, this tongue-in-cheek fractured fairy tale sometimes falls very flat. Still, it's light and action-packed. With well over a dozen major characters, the action gets a bit chaotic by the end but I'm pretty sure that everything gets wrapped up. And Meg even gets to start taking sword fighting lessons (and toss aside her hated embroidery)!
Sunday, September 01, 2019
Saving Red, by Sonya Sones
Molly and her emotional-support dog Pixie are stuck in the middle of doing last-minute community service work when they meet Red. Without a lot of options for completing her assignment, Molly's participating in a census of homeless people in Santa Monica. While she's certainly been aware of the homeless, she's never given them much thought until now. Red, a young woman of about her age, strikes home in a way for which Molly is not prepared.
Molly becomes obsessed with helping her, but Red is distrustful and rejects Molly's advances. As the story unfolds, it soon becomes clear that Molly is just as in need of help. She may have a physical structure over her head, but she is nearly as abandoned by her absent parents, her family torn apart by a tragedy. The relationship, remaining tentative and never entirely trusting, becomes mutually respectful.
The ultimate resolution of this story-in-verse is both an affirmation of life and a sobering reminder that problems like mental illness and homelessness are not easily solved. Sones takes advantage of the ambiguity of verse to let questions that are unanswerable stay unanswered, while leaving us with hope. Molly and Red are both compelling characters and their relationship complex and subtly interdependent, as the savior becomes the saved. A romantic subplot involving a boy that Molly meets early in the novel is probably the major weak point -- a distraction in a story that didn't need a pretty boy in it -- but Sones always does romance so sweetly that it's hard to begrudge her a few pages of love poetry. This is certainly not Sones's best work, but it is still a decent read and a good use of verse in a novel.
Molly becomes obsessed with helping her, but Red is distrustful and rejects Molly's advances. As the story unfolds, it soon becomes clear that Molly is just as in need of help. She may have a physical structure over her head, but she is nearly as abandoned by her absent parents, her family torn apart by a tragedy. The relationship, remaining tentative and never entirely trusting, becomes mutually respectful.
The ultimate resolution of this story-in-verse is both an affirmation of life and a sobering reminder that problems like mental illness and homelessness are not easily solved. Sones takes advantage of the ambiguity of verse to let questions that are unanswerable stay unanswered, while leaving us with hope. Molly and Red are both compelling characters and their relationship complex and subtly interdependent, as the savior becomes the saved. A romantic subplot involving a boy that Molly meets early in the novel is probably the major weak point -- a distraction in a story that didn't need a pretty boy in it -- but Sones always does romance so sweetly that it's hard to begrudge her a few pages of love poetry. This is certainly not Sones's best work, but it is still a decent read and a good use of verse in a novel.
Extraordinary Birds, by Sandy Stark-McGinnis
In the time in which December has been shunted from one foster home to another, she's learned never to expect permanency in her life. But that's alright, because she has a secret: some day she'll complete her transformation into a bird and fly away. Birds have simple needs: they only need to survive. December looks forward to that simpler life.
In the meantime, she's been placed with Eleanor, a woman whose love of birds speaks to December's heart. Eleanor introduces December to animal rehab work and helps December reconnect with her own humanity. A subplot involving December's friendship with a transgender classmate hangs awkwardly in the story, but provides some room to expand on December's unrecognized ability to empathize.
Ultimately heartwarming, the story is driven by December's comments about the differences and similarities between birds and humans. Perhaps a bit overly precocious for her age, these observations nonetheless will prove enjoyable to readers who love birds in the first place. The story of how Eleanor's patient and gentle rescue of December will appeal to everyone.
In the meantime, she's been placed with Eleanor, a woman whose love of birds speaks to December's heart. Eleanor introduces December to animal rehab work and helps December reconnect with her own humanity. A subplot involving December's friendship with a transgender classmate hangs awkwardly in the story, but provides some room to expand on December's unrecognized ability to empathize.
Ultimately heartwarming, the story is driven by December's comments about the differences and similarities between birds and humans. Perhaps a bit overly precocious for her age, these observations nonetheless will prove enjoyable to readers who love birds in the first place. The story of how Eleanor's patient and gentle rescue of December will appeal to everyone.
Friday, August 30, 2019
A Kind of Paradise, by Amy Rebecca Tan
Straight-A student Jamie has messed up badly. Blinded by her desire to impress a boy that she has a crush on, she's been caught violating her school's Honor Code. As a consequence, she has to spend the summer doing community service. There will be no camp and no vacation trips. Instead, she has to work at her town's public library.
But to her surprise, Jamie quickly discovers that the library is full of lots of fun people (both staff and patrons) and that the work is actually pretty interesting as well. Moreover, the people have lessons to impart, helping Jamie see where she went wrong and develop her interpersonal skills along the way. In return, Jamie helps an effort to save the library from closure.
Half a love letter to public libraries and the other half a personal development story, there's lots going on here. Given the target audience, very little of it is subtle. The ending is all a bit too rosy for me as just about everything works out. I didn't find the dialogue very realistic, but the characters are quirky, charming, and memorable.
But to her surprise, Jamie quickly discovers that the library is full of lots of fun people (both staff and patrons) and that the work is actually pretty interesting as well. Moreover, the people have lessons to impart, helping Jamie see where she went wrong and develop her interpersonal skills along the way. In return, Jamie helps an effort to save the library from closure.
Half a love letter to public libraries and the other half a personal development story, there's lots going on here. Given the target audience, very little of it is subtle. The ending is all a bit too rosy for me as just about everything works out. I didn't find the dialogue very realistic, but the characters are quirky, charming, and memorable.
Hope and Other Punch Lines, by Julie Buxbaum
Perhaps one of the most iconic photographs from 9/11 is the one of “Baby
Hope.” You know the one with the one year-old baby girl in a princess dress being rushed
away from the Towers after the first plane hit. But sixteen years later, Abbi wishes everyone would just forget about it. She’s endured endless moments of recognition from strangers, who want to hug her and tell her how much that picture meant to them (as
if she had actually done anything!). All she wants is to enjoy a quiet summer, when - just for once - she can just be herself and not some icon of a horrific event.
But two things lurk over her to prevent this. The first is a persistent and worsening cough, which may be a
legacy of toxins she was exposed to when the Towers collapsed.
The other problem is a persistent boy named Noah. Noah has an obsession: he wants Abbi to help
him track down the other people in that
famous picture. To Abbi, this is the type of painful and tiresome task she is trying to avoid, but Noah has good reasons and
they are ultimately devastating
I really enjoyed this original take on 9/11, a topic which
is fairly remote to today’s young readers. By looking at it in the contemporary moment, seeing the long-term
effects of the event through today's young people is genius stroke, giving the idea relevance and immediacy. Buxbaum is an excellent writer and has
managed to fit in a lot of true stories amidst her admittedly simple story.
Pretty much all of the specifics of the novel (including the “Baby Hope” photo)
are made up, but they are all based on real
events, people, and facts. It’s this
sort of painless education which always impresses me. Unique and recommended.
How It Feels to Float, by Helena Fox
Almost ten years ago, Biz lost her father to depression. While his suicide made her sad initially, she felt better when he came
back to her and spoke to her when she needed him. This was not so unusual for her. Lots of other things speak to her: the ocean, the photographs she takes with Dad’s old film camera, and so many other things. But what about the new boy at school with a mysterious limp? The one who
rescued Biz from the waves when the ocean was convincing her to join it? He doesn’t speak to her, but she wishes he would!
After a traumatic event pushes Biz into outcast status and
gets her suspended from school, her happy world collapses around her. Lost in depression, she determines that the only thing she can do that would make any sense is to seek out the
places where her father lived and see if they (or him) would speak to her again. So, she goes out on a quest to find her father and join him under the water…where he drowned himself.
A fresh, albeit occasionally creepy look at life with
inherited psychosis. As Biz makes her own descent into madness, she's all too aware that she’s following her father’s path, but less and
less concerned about what that could mean for her. There’s something quite gentle and beautiful
about the way that her world falls apart, which makes the journey all the more terrifying. The reader is forced to take the
plunge with her.
In a field with a lot
of similar books about mental illness, I found Biz a compelling character and the story an excellent
read.
Saturday, August 24, 2019
Goodnight, Anne, by Kallie George
It's bedtime for Anne, but before she can nod off, she wants to wish everyone a goodnight. Whether it is Marilla or Matthew, her bosom friend Diana, or even horrid Gilbert, Anne (with an e, thank you!) has a bedtime wish for them all.
A charming bedtime picture book that will please small children with its pretty artwork by Genenieve Godbout, but is far more rewarding for older ones who are familiar with Anne of Green Gables. They will delight in remembering Anne's adventures as they drift off to sleep. If you find "goodnight" books to be dull and boring, you may end up giving this a pass, but for fans of L. M. Montgomery's classic, this is a sweet diversion.
A charming bedtime picture book that will please small children with its pretty artwork by Genenieve Godbout, but is far more rewarding for older ones who are familiar with Anne of Green Gables. They will delight in remembering Anne's adventures as they drift off to sleep. If you find "goodnight" books to be dull and boring, you may end up giving this a pass, but for fans of L. M. Montgomery's classic, this is a sweet diversion.
Friday, August 23, 2019
The Raven's Tale, by Cat Winters
A whimsical biography of Edgar Allan Poe's early years, set mostly on Poe's year away at UVA. Torn between two muses (one that embraces the macabre and another young Eddy's Byronesque romantic side), Edgar struggles to find his way and choose what sort of writer he wishes to be. But most of all, he wrestles with his stepfather's aim of destroying his literary ambitions altogether. I call it whimsical because Poe's muses in this story are incarnate, visible, and interacting with the people around them.
An interesting concept that I found hard to get into. Partly, it is hard to follow the cast of characters (most of whom are based on real people but not being already familiar with Poe's life, were hard to keep track of). Partly, it was the story's uneven pacing. But mostly, it is the supernatural elements of the story (the muses and their rather corporeal magic, which is itself intended to to have a Poe-like tenor). If I was a Poe fan, then Winter's riff would probably be more meaningful. But as a story on its own, it just doesn't have much going for it despite the obvious love and dedication of the writer to the hero.
An interesting concept that I found hard to get into. Partly, it is hard to follow the cast of characters (most of whom are based on real people but not being already familiar with Poe's life, were hard to keep track of). Partly, it was the story's uneven pacing. But mostly, it is the supernatural elements of the story (the muses and their rather corporeal magic, which is itself intended to to have a Poe-like tenor). If I was a Poe fan, then Winter's riff would probably be more meaningful. But as a story on its own, it just doesn't have much going for it despite the obvious love and dedication of the writer to the hero.
Astrid the Unstoppable, by Maria Parr
Astrid is a thunderbolt, a force of nature in her mountain
home of Glimmerdale. Her joys in life consist of sledding down hills, singing at the top of her lungs, and driving grumpy Mr.
Hagen crazy (children, in his opinion, should be silent and kept indoors). But amidst the beauty of her Nordic paradise, there is something she lacks: some other children with
whom to play.
The novel covers three important events in Astrid's life: First of all, her efforts to ride a sled all the way from her high mountain home down to the town on the shore of the fjord. Then, secondly, the moment when her dream of having other children come is answered but it seems that the children will go away almost as soon as they arrive. And ultimately with the return of a young
woman that Astrid never even knew existed.
Inspired by Heidi
(and a bit by Pippi Longstocking as well), Astrid fits comfortably into the tradition of irrepressible young heroines. The book, translated from Norwegian, is
quirky and very much a cultural artifact – written in a style that makes it
seem old fashioned, even though it is set in modern day. The fact that the children are always playing
outdoors and no Game Boys, texting, or Net Flix are to be found can be disconcerting. Like Johanna
Spyri, the author of Heidi, Parr
promotes the benefits of outdoor living and that can seem anachronistic for a contemporary novel. But as alien as the setting may be, Astrid's joyfulness and energy has universal appeal.
Saturday, August 17, 2019
Running through Sprinklers, by Michelle Kim
Sara is looking forward to spending the last year of middle school with her best friend Nadine. However, at the end of summer Nadine announces that she's skipping a grade and starting high school. It isn't just that they are spending the year in different schools. Suddenly Nadine is too busy to spend time with Sara and scoffs at Sara's "childish" ideas. In anger, Sara makes friends with Nadine's little sister, but it doesn't help bring the girls back together.
I tend to like these bittersweet and nostalgic stories of friends growing apart. They are certainly common in books for middle grade readers. This one, though, is surprisingly cluttered. Full of subplots (including a strange abduction story that just is left dangling in the end), the story gets overwhelmed but everything else. There's bra shopping and the first periods as one would expect for a book targeted for girls in this age group, but even coming of age seems buried, despite its obvious relationship to Sara and Nadine's estrangement. Critics have lauded the book for its multicultural elements (both Sara and Nadine are bi-racial) but while a certain amount of attention is spent on Sara's Korean heritage, it's hardly an important element. The book is just noisy and distracting.
I tend to like these bittersweet and nostalgic stories of friends growing apart. They are certainly common in books for middle grade readers. This one, though, is surprisingly cluttered. Full of subplots (including a strange abduction story that just is left dangling in the end), the story gets overwhelmed but everything else. There's bra shopping and the first periods as one would expect for a book targeted for girls in this age group, but even coming of age seems buried, despite its obvious relationship to Sara and Nadine's estrangement. Critics have lauded the book for its multicultural elements (both Sara and Nadine are bi-racial) but while a certain amount of attention is spent on Sara's Korean heritage, it's hardly an important element. The book is just noisy and distracting.
Friday, August 16, 2019
Eventown, by Corey Ann Haydu
Eventown is a perfect place. In it, the most beautiful roses grow, food is delicious, everyone is perfect, and every house looks the same. The people are happy and content, but all extreme emotions have been banished. Everyone is even. Everyone is the same.
Elodee and her twin sister Naomi are turning twelve and drifting apart. The easy bond that they once had has frayed by a family trauma. So when Mom gets a job offer in Eventown, moving and starting a new life sounds like a great idea. And while Elodee has reservations about some of the strange things about their new home, she likes how nice everyone is and how easy the life is. But over time, Elodee's reservations grow stronger and she finds herself rebelling against the "even" way of life. This proves to have severe consequences for Elodee, her family, and the town as a whole.
A peculiar and fascinating tale that explores the costs and benefits of sacrificing risk and chance for the security of an unchanging world. While written for middle graders, the subject matter (which is ultimately about enduring tragic loss) seems a bit heavy for the target audience. The metaphor of the utopia also seems likely to be lost on them. Adults however will find that the book has a lot to say in the end about love, community, memory, and the value of embracing differences. It's a beautiful and haunting story.
Elodee and her twin sister Naomi are turning twelve and drifting apart. The easy bond that they once had has frayed by a family trauma. So when Mom gets a job offer in Eventown, moving and starting a new life sounds like a great idea. And while Elodee has reservations about some of the strange things about their new home, she likes how nice everyone is and how easy the life is. But over time, Elodee's reservations grow stronger and she finds herself rebelling against the "even" way of life. This proves to have severe consequences for Elodee, her family, and the town as a whole.
A peculiar and fascinating tale that explores the costs and benefits of sacrificing risk and chance for the security of an unchanging world. While written for middle graders, the subject matter (which is ultimately about enduring tragic loss) seems a bit heavy for the target audience. The metaphor of the utopia also seems likely to be lost on them. Adults however will find that the book has a lot to say in the end about love, community, memory, and the value of embracing differences. It's a beautiful and haunting story.
Sunday, August 11, 2019
Are You Ready to Hatch an Unusual Chicken? by Kelly Jones
In this sequel to Unusual Chickens for the Exceptional Poultry Farmer, Sophie continues her explorations of raising chickens. Now the proud owner of Agnes's old farm, Sophie is challenged with the process of fixing the place up and reestablishing the farm's poultry business, starting with hatching some new chickens. And while the chickens may have extraordinary powers, the business of hatching and raising is pretty much the same as with normal chickens. Learning all of that and soliciting the help and input of her community teaches Sophie a lot about humans and chickens alike.
As with the first book, a small dose of fantasy (teleporting and fire-breathing chickens) aside, this is a story about a girl working hard to achieve her goals. Packed full of useful and interesting instructions about chicken care, this delightful story will entice readers to learn more about chickens. Gently delivered messages about tolerance and forgiveness add substance. Copious illustrations throughout provide the icing on the cake. Fun, educational, affirming, and pretty to flip through -- what more could you ask of a middle reader?
As with the first book, a small dose of fantasy (teleporting and fire-breathing chickens) aside, this is a story about a girl working hard to achieve her goals. Packed full of useful and interesting instructions about chicken care, this delightful story will entice readers to learn more about chickens. Gently delivered messages about tolerance and forgiveness add substance. Copious illustrations throughout provide the icing on the cake. Fun, educational, affirming, and pretty to flip through -- what more could you ask of a middle reader?
Friday, August 09, 2019
The Surface Breaks, by Louise O'Neill
Gaia and her sisters are mermaids, living off the coast of
Ireland. In their society, men are in charge and their duty is to be demure and subservient to men in general and the Sea King in particular. He in turn uses her daughters to reward his most loyal soldiers.
Gaia, who has just turned fifteen has been informed that she will be given away to the odious (and much older) Zale. The idea repulses her. Her mother, who might have stood up for her, is gone. She was lost many years ago when she went to the surface and was captured and tortured by the humans.
And much more was lost. It was Gaia's mother who had carefully crafted peace between the mer-people and the wraith-like Rusalki (the spirits of wronged women who skulk in the dark and attempt to lure sailors to their death). But since her death, the King, Zale, and the other mer-men have been plotting war.
For her birthday, Gaia has been granted the opportunity
to go to the surface for the first time. Mindful of her mother's fate, she is cautious, but nonetheless she becomes enchanted by Oliver, a human boy. Aware that she has no chance with him in
her fishy form, she makes a bargain with a sea witch: she will be granted human legs but only for a
short period. In that period she has to
get Oliver to love her. Otherwise, she
will die.
A grisly and dark retelling of The Little Mermaid with a strong feminist twist that becomes
especially pronounced in the ending. It
works but I found the story depressing.
The essential message seems to be:
love is pain and suffering, while freedom from men is death. It’s well within the eco-feminist cannon
(although perhaps a bit more Andrea Dworkin than Susan Griffin), but this isn't usual territory for YA. Curious and original, but it is hard to
imagine this dark and unhappy story finding much of an audience.
[Disclosure: I received an ARC in return for an unbiased review.]
Not If I Can Help It, by Carolyn Mackler
Willa has issues with things
around her that feel wrong. A sensory processing disorder makes certain
sights, sounds, smells, tastes, or feels for her entirely unbearable. Every day is a struggle but through routine
she is able to manage her adverse reactions. But any change is a challenge. She definitely doesn't like changes!
So when her father announces that he’s dating again, Willa isn't happy. Worse, his girlfriend isn't some stranger, but rather the mother of Willa’s BFF
Ruby. Willa is not OK with the idea of
Dad having a girlfriend. As much as
she loves Ruby, she doesn’t want Ruby to be her sister. But change is in the air and Willa has to
learn to cope with it.
A short, but well-written middle reader about a condition that
I don’t believe has been touched on before. Willa's hypersensitivity can make her seem difficult, but Mackler navigates that challenge well, showing how difficult these situations are for her. At the same time, everyone’s a bit too perfect for my tastes (Willa’s parents in
particular deserve some major reward!), but it’s a kind story that really just
is focused on Willa’s difficulties. That
might be the bigger issue: while we get
a good picture of Willa’s struggles, there’s not much growth here. So, the pattern is Willa finds out about a
change and then gets upset and then eventually moves on. Repeat.
That’s actually pretty dull over the expanse of an entire novel.
[Disclosure: I
received an ARC from the publisher in return for an unbiased review]
Friday, August 02, 2019
Mun Mun, by Jesse Andrews
In this most striking science fiction novel of 2018 that you've never heard of, Mun Mun describes a world where your net worth defines your physical size. Based on the amount of "mun mun" (money) you have, you can be anywhere from the "littlepoor" (about the size of a squirrel) to "bigrich" (where the sky's the limit on size and height). Being as small as a rodent has some significant disadvantages, ranging from having trouble working at a normal job to simply not being eaten as a snack by a free-range kitty.
Littlepoors Warner and his sister Prayer have dreams of making some mun mun of their own and maybe becoming middlepoor some day, but their plans run astray and Warner ends up in jail. But then a well-meaning family of middleriches rescues him, trying to prove that, with a little mun mun, anyone can pull themselves out of poverty and littleness. But as the author grindingly makes clear, mun mun by itself can't change the legacy of who you are and where you came from.
With a wit that owes much more to Jonathan Swift's satire than any modern day dystopian novel, Andrews says a lot about class, privilege, and the inherent flaw in so many well-intended attempts to "fix" these social evils. The result can be depressing at points, but just as Gulliver's Travels was able to say so much of contemporary relevance in its day through fantasy, Andrews knows that the message is so much clearer when you are not expecting it. It's unwillingness to embrace either Left or Right will probably upset some folks, but there's little to argue with here.
The ending grows a bit weird as Warner becomes unhinged from his suffering and his character transforms to a dark anti-hero with whom it becomes hard to identify and sympathize, but the originality and biting observations of this allegory make this novel a stand-out work. It's a largely neglected book that deserves a wider audience. Highly recommended.
Littlepoors Warner and his sister Prayer have dreams of making some mun mun of their own and maybe becoming middlepoor some day, but their plans run astray and Warner ends up in jail. But then a well-meaning family of middleriches rescues him, trying to prove that, with a little mun mun, anyone can pull themselves out of poverty and littleness. But as the author grindingly makes clear, mun mun by itself can't change the legacy of who you are and where you came from.
With a wit that owes much more to Jonathan Swift's satire than any modern day dystopian novel, Andrews says a lot about class, privilege, and the inherent flaw in so many well-intended attempts to "fix" these social evils. The result can be depressing at points, but just as Gulliver's Travels was able to say so much of contemporary relevance in its day through fantasy, Andrews knows that the message is so much clearer when you are not expecting it. It's unwillingness to embrace either Left or Right will probably upset some folks, but there's little to argue with here.
The ending grows a bit weird as Warner becomes unhinged from his suffering and his character transforms to a dark anti-hero with whom it becomes hard to identify and sympathize, but the originality and biting observations of this allegory make this novel a stand-out work. It's a largely neglected book that deserves a wider audience. Highly recommended.
A Week of Mondays, by Jessica Brody
Ellie is having the worst Monday ever. Her parents are fighting, she gets a ticket
for running a red light on the way to school, and her hair is ruined in the
rain and it’s school picture day. In
rapid succession, she then flubs a quiz, botches her campaign speech for class vice
president due to a food allergy, and fails her tryouts for varsity softball. To top it all off, at the end of the day
her boyfriend dumps her. What she
wouldn’t give for a do-over!
And then she gets the chance: her whole horrible Monday repeats all
over again. With the advantage of foresight, some things she can fix but others are worse for the meddling. But our chances are far from over and the day repeats again. She gets to tinker with and tweak this fateful day, never quite
fixing it, because she’s really missing the big picture.
This would be the second Groundhog
Day rip-off I’ve read this summer (see Opposite of Always on July 6th for the other one). It’s a cute device, of course, and overflowing with comic potential. In this case, it also has a weightier moral about being oneself instead of trying to be perfect
for others.
The book does have a decent heroine and
a fun story going for it. The guys are largely
throwaway but Ellie is sympathetic with the right mix of skills and mistakes to
make her believable. It makes for
pleasant reading even if not treading much new ground.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)