Sonia is bright and hard working. She's determined to be the first member of her family to graduate from high school. However, sometimes she simply can't get to school because her family needs her. Family is everything. And in her family, the girl takes care of the house. Her brothers are free to run around and do as they please, but it is Sonia's job to prepare the meals and clean the house. If there is time afterwards to do homework and go to school, then she can go. Faced with this burden, it is a challenge to keep up her attendance. Her teachers are unsympathetic and wherever she turns, she can find no allies. At home her mother lazes around and a freeloading aunt and a lecherous uncle add to her misery.
A grueling litany of the socioeconomic forces working against a young Latina. Written specifically for reluctant readers, Sitomer obviously hopes that the subject matter will resonate with Latinx readers in similar positions in real life. It's a noble goal, but I'm more intrested in examining the book on its own merits
It is an interesting peek at a world far removed from most of us. Sonia is very strong and determined and easy to root for. The book is easy to read and the regular insertion of Spanish into the text feels natural and non-intrusive. One does tire of the idealism and generalizations (hearing how all Mexicans behave, how all men behave, etc.) and some of the events (a trip to Mexico, a race riot at school, etc.) seem stuffed in for no reason except to provide us discussion topics for a classroom reading. Still, I think this is a good book in spite of its pedagogical ambitions. I enjoyed it.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment