While infused with a feminist message and a gender inclusive world, this is not a terribly message-heavy story. Rather, it was more of a traditional hack-and-slash fantasy novel, albeit with a dizzying array of characters. The first forty pages or so are stuffed with footnotes, which while a bit distracting, are largely indispensable for understanding the rest of the story. Despite that copious background development, I had largely lost track of the characters and the importance of various villains by the end. I would strongly suggest keeping notes on who is who as you go as characters reappear and earlier events have a habit of becoming important later. That is all a sign of good construction but I still found it a bit too much! Too much work to be enjoyable.
Thursday, June 09, 2022
A Thousand Steps Into Night, by Traci Chee
Saturday, June 04, 2022
Prepped, by Bethany Mangle
She's earned a scholarship for college and plans to leave after graduation. But when a terrible accident occurs, the compound's belief in end times hits a higher intensity and Becca has to decide what she is willing to sacrifice to have her freedom and her dreams of a future not weighted down by fear.
A well-paced survival story that never really generated much interest in its characters. They are largely two-dimensional, especially Becca's abusive mother. I took Becca's love for her little sister at face value, because I never saw any real evidence of it. And the romance between Becca and Roy largely fell flat. It won't give you much insight into preppers but the setting at least allowed for an entertaining adventure.
Monday, May 30, 2022
Loveless, by Alice Oseman
It's not like she hasn't thought about it, but whenever she tries to think of someone she'd like to date, it doesn't seem right. And kissing? Eww! And no, she's not gay either -- girls hold no more interest for her than boys. Friends and family try to reassure her that she'll get there eventually. Someday, she'll meet her "special someone." But she doesn't believe it.
So, what does that mean? If she never feels a sexual attraction or a romantic desire, is she destined to end up alone and lonely? Will her friends drift away as they marry off and start families, leaving her to live by herself? Is there such a thing as love without romance? Is there life without love?
Oseman's groundbreaking novel of an aro/ace young woman explores the sexual orientations that aren't -- asexuality and aromantic (that's the tail end of the LGBTQIA+ acronym, by the way) . I have only passing familiarity with the concept (if knowing two ace people in real life counts) so this was all a big education for me. My jury's still out about my personal feelings about asexuality as an identity, but the fact that Georgia identifies with it is enough for me to be interested in learning more. This is a fairly painless way to do so.
However, I found the novel a bit of a chore. Written in a fanfic style that rambles on and on, Loveless is a long soap opera of the first year of college, with lots of bed hopping, too much alcohol, and very little studying. It comes off like a non-hetero British version of Felicity and can be just as grating. The writing is in desperate need of an editor and a lot of trimming. The protagonists break character frequently, when they are not repeating themselves.
Sunday, May 29, 2022
The Gilded Ones, by Namina Forna
From the prison where she is being held, a stranger rescues her. The stranger won't give her name, but Deka takes to calling her "White Hands" and the name sticks. Deka is taken to a training camp where she meets other "impure" girls. They are called the alaki and are condemned as abominations and demons by men. But they are also super strong and incapable of easily being killed and so feared as well. This combination of revulsion and fear permeates the rest of the novel as Deka and her sisterhood of aleki are trained by White Hands and other women to help rid their lands of even more fearsome demons called "deathshrieks."
The training and preparations for a final battle of men and the despised (and indispensable) aleki against their shared foe becomes complicated as Deka starts to develop strange powers. As she learns to master these powers, she becomes simultaneously more knowledgeable of the deathshrieks. In the end, she comes to understand that she is fighting for the wrong cause.
This rich tale of female empowerment has a surprisingly upbeat ending, but the story doesn't start out that way. It's a pretty grisly tale full of gore and violence. Female endangerment features prominently throughout the story. I would hesitate to accuse it of being gratuitous since the violence itself is integral to the story, but the sheer mass of it may turn some readers off. It's that brutality that has probably earned Forna the moniker of being "the Toni Morrison of fantasy YA." The drama itself, covering the damage of patriarchal misogyny and the damage it has wrought is hardly new material, but her treatment of PTSD in its victims is a a rarity.
I actually had a different issue with the book. Forna does a poor job of allowing her story to unfold. Instead, major plot developments appear out of thin air as important details are simply dropped into the story, unconnected to anything that occurred prior. Much of the drama of the story relies on the late introductions. Still, despite its flaw, the novel is an immersive and easy read.
If you want more, the novel's sequel, The Merciless Ones will be released on Tuesday.
Saturday, May 28, 2022
Da Vinci's Cat, by Catherine Gilbert Murdock
Young Federico, kept hostage by the Pope, is on friendly terms with the artist Raphael and familiar with the far grumpier Michelangelo. They are fine artists but he doesn't understand the intense interest in them from strangers wearing strange clothes who appear out of a closet in the Palace. These strangers are desperate to acquire cast offs from Raphael and Michelangelo. Even rough sketches excite them (especially if they are signed)! And in return, they bring Federico the most delicious sweets, made from something called "chocolate." Federico has never tasted anything better in his life and sees no harm in absconding with a drawing or two in exchange for more of it. But when Bee shows up, history is changed and only the cat seems to understand it all, and she doesn't say much.
An amusing time travel story with some educational value from the attention it gives to the artistry of Raphael and Michelangelo and to its many lovely details about everyday life in 16th century Italy. The story doesn't always pace well and some parts get confusing (as is true with many time-travel stories!), but it is entertaining. Absolutely lovely sketches of the cat Juno throughout the novel are a high point.
Thursday, May 26, 2022
That Thing About Bollywood, by Supriya Kelkar
The pressure drives her so crazy that an unexpected thing happens: her life becomes a Bollywood film! Now, when things get bas, she breaks out into lavish song and dance numbers. Colors become brighter. A musical soundtrack starts up. The people around her become a chorus and background dancers. In her songs, Sonali finally expresses her real feelings. She calls it "Bollywooditis," where music, dancing, and a larger-than-life world becomes the only place Sonali can be heard. But she knows that it is not real and as much as she loves it, she wants things to be normal again.
This magical Disney-esque conceit serves as a loving tribute to Bollywood and all of its camp. While the story itself is fairly basic and carries no particular surprises, it becomes a vehicle for Kelkar to bring up all of her beloved tropes of "filmi magic." For a Westerner with limited exposure to Bollywood (I once shared an apartment with a group of Indian students who watched nothing else all summer), I could recognize and appreciate only some of the references, but for true fans there is a lot to enjoy. Kelkar pulls out all the classic ingredients and creates a story that puts American middle school drama into the Bollyverse. I enjoyed the novelty of the concept and the sweet way that it was implemented. Perhaps I should watch a filmi again?
Sunday, May 22, 2022
How Not to Fall in Love, by Jacqueline Firkins
But her best friend, boy-next-door Theo, is in complete disagreement. For him, there is nothing greater than love and he proves it by falling in love every week! And overtures are spurned, the objects of his affection flee, and his heart inevitably crushed, he picks up the pieces and finds another girl to chase. Theo's hobby (LARPing) with it's drama and romance feeds his obsession and his perpetual optimism. He loves the whole idea of the grand gesture.
Theo despairs that he'll never be fully happy. Harper thinks he should stop trying so hard. She promises him that if he would just relax and stop making such a big deal out of love, he could be happy. He argues that she is in no position to judge because she's never been in love. A challenge is hatched: they will prove each other wrong. And, of course, since this is a rom-com, it will all go completely off-plan, surprising the two of them when they find each other in the end.
Based on the classic trope of the girl dating the wrong guy in order to find the right one, we have all the basic ingredients in place: the long suffering (and coincidentally, cute!) neighbor boy, the studly (and wrong) initial love interest, and the supportive BFF who selflessly supports Harper. Fabulous bridal shop anecdotes provide humor (a function also provided by some brief LARPing). A very supportive mother helps Harper sort through her adolescent angst. Some pretty hot sex scenes spice things up. At the end of it all, a completely over-the-top public confession adds the cherry on the top of this caloric romantic confection.
Wednesday, May 18, 2022
True Letters from a Fictional Life, by Kenneth Logan
For all of his life, James has struggled with these thoughts: finding the courage to say what he really feels. He wonders if any of it is worth saying. He questions what he really wants. When he meets a gay boy named Topher, it motivates him to step out. He's afraid of what will happen but taking things slow is OK and seem to be going well. But then someone breaks into his desk drawer and steals his letters. And they start showing up in people's mailboxes.
I found this story disorganized and unfocused. The pace is uneven and aimless. I never really got a sense about what James saw in Topher and about why he was willing to come out because of him. The great letter fiasco proved to be anti-climactic. And Teresa, who could have been all sorts of things to this story about coming out, just came off as selfish and annoying, with little indication of where her appeal to him ever lay. So, while I was sympathetic to James, he didn't seem to have interesting friends or an interesting life. I never engaged with the story.
Saturday, May 14, 2022
A Place to Hang the Moon, by Kate Albus
It is their solicitor who lands on the idea of having the children join in the evacuation of London, pretend to leave their parents behind, and settle with a host family in the countryside. Preposterous as it might sound, perhaps they will uncover a suitable foster home? A place where, as the children put it, they might find someone who thinks that they "hang the moon."
Reality is much harder of course and the children find themselves shuttled from one unsuitable place to another. Faced with different types of abuse and neglect, the one bright spot in their lives is a kindly librarian, Mrs. Müller. The children adore her and she reciprocates, but she cannot host them. She has been judged an unsuitable guardian due to the questionable loyalty of her husband, a German national who left her and disappeared at the outbreak of the War.
The orphan genre is truly a golden part of children's literature and this one pays homage to the greats. It's a predictable formula but one that is very effective. It combines adventure as the children face peril and yet emerge happily in the end in the arms of a loving family. The emotional pay off is strong. In this particular case, period detail about the evacuation of children into the countryside gives us some meaty subject matter as well. The result is an enjoyable and memorable read. Recommended.
Friday, May 13, 2022
Daughter of the White Rose, by Diane Zahler
Sunday, May 08, 2022
365 Days to Alaska, by Cathy Carr
But she knows a secret. Before she left, her Dad promised that, if she could just make it through the next year, that he would find a way to let her come back and live with him. So now she keeps herself going by counting down the days before she can go back home. However, as the number of days dwindle, her father becomes more distant and unreliable. She also begins to realize that maybe Connecticut isn't so bad and that home is where you make it.
While hardly surprising material, the book charms with its main character. Rigel is an engaging heroine with a strong will and a deep and enchanting love of nature. Her confidence, derived from the life in the wild, serves her well in negotiating the hostile halls of middle school. Her supportive family allows Rigel the space she needs to make the transition to the "outside" world. Enjoyable, with lots of fun anecdotes about living in remote Alaska.
Friday, May 06, 2022
Of a Feather, by Dayna Lorentz
Reenie is an eighth grader, uprooted from her home and school, and transplanted with an aunt that she hardly knows. Her mother suffers from depression and keeps falling apart, leaving Reenie in an insecure state. From her struggles, Reenie has learned that she can't trust anyone and so she never does. But at her new school, she slowly warms to a boy and a girl in her class and forms friendships.
More importantly, Reenie's aunt is an animal rehabilitation specialist and a falconer. While initially skeptical of her aunt's activities, Reenie quickly is enchanted by the birds. Exploiting Reenie's enthusiasm, her aunt enlists her assistance. Her aunt even helps Reenies try to capture a falcon of her own to train. But instead of a falcon, they capture an injured Great Horned Owl.
Owls are largely untrainable, her aunt warns her, but this one forms an inexplicable bond with Reenie and the two of them regain their confidence together and learn to reach out again. However, as with all wild animals, Reenie must learn to let go of Rufus once he has finished his rehabilitation.
A terribly sweet story highlighted by numerous interesting bird facts and some very funny owl dialog. While the story may be a bit contrived, the message about trust, family, and being brave plays very nicely through both of the story's protagonists. The anthropomorphism is less jarring than one would think as it draws on known owl behavior. A truly delightful read!
Sunday, May 01, 2022
Almost There and Almost Not, by Linda Urban
The Star Outside My Window, by Onjali Q. Rauf
There is a complication. As a promotional stunt, the Royal Observatory is holding a contest to name the star. Anjali knows she has to make sure that no one gives her mother the wrong name, but what can she do about it? The contest has tens of thousands of entrants (and children aren't allowed to enter anyway!) so she has no way to effect a result directly. She'll have to go and explain to the adults that they can't give her mother's star a different name. Getting from Waverly Village (outside of Oxford) to Greenwich seems an insurmountable task for a ten year-old, but with some help from her friends, she and Noah set out on their bicycles to prevent the Observatory from giving the new star a wrong name.
Holding aside the breathtaking danger of the premise, this is a stirring adventure with resourceful children sticking together and accomplishing their goals. Tt is all wrapped up a bit too neatly, but along the way the children get to show a few skills. The suppressed memories that prove the motive for Anjali's obsession with naming the star have a poignancy to them that gives the story some weight. Spending more time addressing those feelings would have fleshed the story out better, but (again) this being British kidlit, we don't have much comfort with exploring emotions. Instead, the conclusion has to be that the adults will step in at the end and make everything better and Anjali and her friends don't need to worry themselves over grownup matters. That's not a very empowering message, even if it is motivated by good intentions.
Saturday, April 30, 2022
Rescue at Lake Wild, by Terry Lynn Johnson
Madison has received an ultimatum from her parents: no more strays! If she brings home one more needy animal, the trip they are supposed to take in two weeks to hear and meet Jane Goodall will be off. That's pretty important for Madi, who has been trying to learn as much about wild animals as she can. But when she and her friends find two dead beavers and then rescue two hungry kits, Madi can't help but take the babies home to save them. Keeping her parents from finding the babies is going to take ingenuity, but there is a bigger issue: who is killing the beavers?
A light and delightful adventure and mystery. The storytelling is disjointed and full of loose ends. I wasn't entirely thrilled with the behavior that was being modeled (some of which was seriously dangerous and some of it mildly unlawful). However, the overall intelligence of the story and the good advice about how to interact with wildlife was a net positive. I also enjoyed Madison's strong and inspiring character. Perfect for young animal lovers and anyone who likes cute baby animals.
Friday, April 29, 2022
At the End of Everything, by Marieke Nijkamp
With no one to guard them or take care of them and public attention elsewhere, the kids struggle to take care of themselves. That grows challenging as they run low on supplies, utilities start to fail, and they start getting sick.
While not about a pandemic, this story of survival and coping with the stresses of the mass outbreak of disease draws on the Covid-19 experience, and it does so in a way that is strikingly more effective than any of the books that have been written to date about the Covid Pandemic. Characters voice very familiar fears (about getting sick, distrusting others, longing to be around people, and being anxious about the future) that will feel familiar to all readers. As a story, it never really goes anywhere and some elements (like a trans character) seem to really lack any purpose, but as a study of coping it's actually a fairly engrossing read.
Tuesday, April 26, 2022
Iron Widow, by Xiran Jay Zhao
Huaxia has long been protected by the Great Wall. But defending the empire from swarms of alien Hunduns also requires special robotic war craft called Chrysalises. Run off of the qi of two young pilots, they are capable of mutating into a variety of forms, depending on the level and source of that qi. Proper operation requires a strict hierarchy: in the more powerful yang seat sits the young male pilot. Alongside with him, in the yin seat, sits a young woman. Occasionally, the two co-pilots can balance their qi and become a "perfect match" but far more often the qi of the male overwhelms the female and she is annihilated during combat. So, while a male pilot can be feted as a hero, female pilots are almost always victims. Still, despite the near certainty of death, families willingly sacrifice their girl children for the opportunity to bring glory to the family.
For Zetian, there is another motivation for enlistment altogether. Her older sister was killed by a male pilot and she wants revenge. When she gets it, murdering her male co-pilot in cold blood, she gains the moniker of "the iron widow." To her surprise, she is not killed, but instead is reassigned to co-pilot with Shimin, a notorious psychopath and the holder of the strongest qi in the empire (rumored to be almost as strong as the great lost emperor himself!). The presumption is that he will destroy her in combat but that doesn't happen. Instead, Zetian and Shimin are found to be a perfect match and pitched as the best chance of finally eliminating the Hunduns. Their survival now depends upon making themselves indispensible and they find themselves in an even more dangerous game of intrigue -- a game that may just undermine the foundations of their civilization (if the Hunduns don't get them first!).
A rollercoaster ride of blood-soaked action, full of twists and turns. The plotting is sufficiently byzantine to keep me enthralled and always guessing as to what will come next. Zhao's vision (and the logistics of qi combat in particular) are breathtaking. I won't claim to fully follow the ending of the story, but I did appreciate the true originality of the fight sequences. The Chinese-esque setting is sweeping and beautiful without falling into twee orientalism. It is masterful storytelling.
This is also an uncompromising feminist work. From the obvious (attacks on the politics of foot binding) to the unexpected (a defense of polyamory), the writing is an unrelenting attack on sexism and patriarchy that is nearly as intense as its robot wars. The Chrysalis itself serves a particular sexual function that Zhao exploits in a variety of different ways throughout the story. Who knew that mecha could be so erotic? Or so useful as a literary device?
It's all quite dark though so if you don't like your YA dark, bloody, and unrelentingly political, then this is one to pass by. But by doing so, you are definitely missing one of the best science-fiction YA novels of the past year!
Saturday, April 23, 2022
Mirror Girls, by Kelly McWilliams
But when they get there, Charlie's in for another surprise. There's more to the trip than a dying wish. It's time for a prophecy to be fulfilled. Charlie learns that she has a twin sister, named Magnolia -- a girl who's lily white and been passing as a member of the southern gentry in Eureka. Shortly after the girls were born, their parents were murdered for mixing races. The girls were separated. Their white paternal grandmother wanted Magnolia because she looked white enough to pass as an heir. And she likewise had no use for Charlie. Unable to stop the separation, Charlie's maternal grandmother took Charlie north. But the separation of the twins triggered a series of supernatural events in Eureka. And the reunion eighteen years later rouses old ghosts, the men and women who live in the "veil" between life and death because of the racial injustice they experienced during their lives.
A swirly atmospheric horror story with plenty of magic, but also more grandiose attempts to explore the curse of slavery and racial inequity. I was pretty excited at first at the audacious ambition of the idea. McWilliams's previous novel (Agnes at the End of the World) showed that she had the skills to pull this off. However, despite her affinity with the characters, she doesn't have much understanding of the subject matter. Her vision of the south is largely stereotypes and two-dimensional characters (sadistic white racists, virtuous blacks). There's little of the nuance that would show how the evil of segregation could exist -- the evil that is precisely what the novel is focusing upon). It's all interesting as an idea and the melodramatic finale is surprisingly effective and original, but for the most part the storytelling is simply not executed very well.
Wednesday, April 20, 2022
Willodeen, by Katherine Applegate
The key seems to the decline of the Bumblebears seems to lie with the Screechers -- a unloved pest that plagues the countryside and which only Willodeen seems to appreciate. Most people would prefer to eradicate the Screechers and concerted recent efforts to kill them have been almost successful. Willodeen proves that that was a mistake. However, even after Willodeen discovers the link between the animals, she still has to find the personal strength to present the unfortunate news to the grownups in Perchance, overcoming her fear of public speaking and criticism.
With its ecological theme, Willodeen has a political angle, but it is also a universal story about finding one's voice and learning to articulate it. Both themes are valuable. I felt that the backstory that explains Willodeen's fear of the public was sketchy and could have been better developed, but the depiction of how Willodeen followed the scientific method to identify the interrelation between Screechers and Bumblebears was clever and exciting. A fast read, suitable for early readers but enjoyable to much older ones. Fans of Greta Thunberg should consider the book to be obligatory reading.
Sunday, April 17, 2022
Called Upon, by Bethany Lee
However, the camp itself is strange: largely unsupervised, the kids are free to roam, but they are painfully aware of the watchful gaze of the creepy security guard and their grey-eyed counselors. When campers start to disappear, Kaitlin and some of the others start to get suspicious. And when she falls ill with mysterious symptoms, things turn deadly. She'll have to draw on strengths hidden inside of her and learn to believe in herself.
Adding to the mystery, the story is also told through the perspective of two other characters (Ashley, an unwed mother of twins, and Parker, a young man with an intense hatred of his father). Who these people are and how they fit in with the nefarious affairs of this summer camp unfolds only slowly.
While it starts slow and it takes a while to accept the multiple narrators (especially when it becomes clear that Ashley and Parker don't have much to contribute to the story), Lee does an excellent job of building up her mystery. However, the story becomes less interesting as the implausible truth unfolds. Once things unravel, the explanation just seems silly. It probably works as a juvenile thriller, but really fell apart for me. In the end, I found it entertaining, but not particularly rewarding.